Monday, May 13, 2013
Shiloh
We have been enjoying reading Shiloh and are almost to the end! Write some of you thoughts on the book and the story. What would you do if you were Marty? Do you think he made the right choice in keeping Shiloh hidden at his house? How do you think the story will end? Will Marty get to keep Shiloh?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I think at the end of Shiloh Marty will get to keep Shiloh LOM
ReplyDeleteI think he will keep shiloh if he returns shiloh to his ower then if the ower said if he can keep shiloh.
ReplyDeletemc
What I think will happen is...
ReplyDeleteMarty will become friends with Jude,and Jude will sell Shiloh for less money. And marty will be able to afford him.So Marty buys him and lives happiy ever after. -CLB
If I was Marty I would return him to Jud so he would kick Shiloh.I do not think he made the right choice by keeping Shiloh hidden in the house.I think marty will get to keep Shiloh.R.X
ReplyDeletemarty IS GOING TO KEEP SHILOH. IS
ReplyDeleteYes. Because jed is not caring for his dog. Yes.
ReplyDeleteBecause the dog will get hert from jed. And He is tring to keep it safe.
MS
I would tell just mom,dad,and doc.I would try to keep Shiloh a secret.I think Marty made the right choise.I thinkthe story will end like Marty gets to keep Shiloh.
ReplyDeletegjz
1.If I was Marty I would tell everybody exept Judd Traver that Marty gots Shiloh.
ReplyDelete2.yes I think Marty made a good choice.
3.I think it`ll have a happy ending.
4.I think Marty will get to have Shiloh. s.c
I THINK JUD TRAVERS WILL NOT MISS TREAT HIS DOGS AGAIN.IF I WERE MARTY I WOULD KEEP SHILOH AWAY FROM JUD.ALSO I THINK IT WAS RIGHT TO KEEP SHILOH AT SHILOH AT HIS HOUSE NL
ReplyDeleteI think marty will get to keep shilloh but
ReplyDeletei think jud travers will find out and shilloh will get more better from engerd part
If i was marty i would say that i did not see shiloh .but i would blind myself so i can not see everyone.i think marty is going to ask to his family to help him keep a secert from jud because he wants to hert shiloh but marty wants shiloh to be very very very very very safe and i think he is going teach jud to not aboose shiloh. o.c
ReplyDeleteIf I were Marty I wiil keep Shiloh too. I think marty will keep Shiloh. -ED
ReplyDeletehere he says and it,s a dog,s collar-an old collar, but better than the one shiloh,s got now. might be a litttie big.the end IS
ReplyDeleteI THINK MARTY WILL RETURN SHILOH TO JUDD TRAVERS. IF I WERE MARTY I WILL STILL BE KEEPING IT A SECRET TILL JUDD TRAVERS FIGURES OUT. i THINK MARTY WILL GET TO KEEP SHILOH. i THINK JUDD TRAVERS WILL LET SHILOH GO FOR SALE.
ReplyDeleteLMW
I would keep SHILOH and only tell David, Mom, Dad, Dara Lynn, and Doc Murphy. I think that Jud Travers should treat his dogs better. Yes, I think that Marty did make the right choice to keep Shiloh at his house. I think that Marty will get to keep Shiloh and, I think that his dad will pay to keep Shiloh.
ReplyDeleteKW
I think Marty will give $30 to Jude. Then Jude will give shiloh to Marty.Also I think Marty will tell his friend david howord.
ReplyDeletejh
if i was shiloh i would run away from the german sheperd.Yes i think it was the right choice.thart shiloh will get beter and Marty will get to keep shiloh. rw
ReplyDeleteI think Marty will get Shiloh by working for Judd travers.Also I bet Shiloh will be so happy his tail will fall off.If I were Marty I would see if I cvould make a deal with Judd Travers and agree.I think Marty made both wrong and right choice to keep Shiloh hidden.I think the story will end with a very very very happy ending.I bet that Marty will have enough money to buy Shiloh Judd Travers HAM
ReplyDeleteI think Marty will get to keep shiloh.If I was
ReplyDeleteMarty I wode hide shiloh ina box with holl`s.
K.L.S
if I was Shiloh would punch the seperd.
ReplyDeletecpo